Pages

Thursday, February 25, 2010

Filibuster Success By Party

Congress Years Motions Filed* Votes on Cloture* Cloture Invoked* Successful Filibuster** Senate Majority*** Republican Filibuster Democrat Filibuster
111 2009-2010 75 44 39 5 D 5

110 2007-2008 139 112 61 51 D 51

109 2005-2006 68 54 34 20 R
20
108 2003-2004 62 49 12 37 R
37
107 2001-2002 72 61 34 27 D 27

106 1999-2000 71 58 28 30 R
30
105 1997-1998 69 53 18 35 R
35
104 1995-1996 82 50 9 41 R
41
103 1993-1994 80 46 14 32 D 32

102 1991-1992 59 47 22 25 D 25

101 1989-1990 37 24 11 13 D 13

100 1987-1988 53 43 12 31 D 31

99 1985-1986 40 23 10 13 R
13
98 1983-1984 41 19 11 8 R
8
97 1981-1982 31 30 10 20 R
20
96 1979-1980 30 20 11 9 D 9


Total 1009 733 336 397
193 204










* Data source

** Successful filibuster = votes on cloture - cloture invoked



*** Data source

I was recently challenged regarding my assertion that Democrats have had more successful filibusters in recent history. The source the person used for the challenge is a Washington Post article that analyses the number of cloture "motions filed" and makes the assertion that since this number is higher of late this is somehow a change in the way the senate does business.

My assertion is that over the past 3 decades the filibuster has been used successfully by both parties and in fact the democrats have had more success then the republicans in using the filibuster as a tool to block legislation.

The first point you need to understand is that a motion for cloture means nothing. It is the actual vote for cloture that is important.

The next point is that in order for a filibuster to be blocked the senate has to vote (60 votes required today) to "invoke cloture" (stop debate) thus ending the filibuster.

If you look at the data from the Senate website you will see that going back to the 96th congress the democrats have had 204 successful filibusters while the republicans have had 193 successful filibusters.

I also find it interesting that the same people complaining about the filibuster are also talking about the tyranny of the majority.

Friday, February 12, 2010

Places I Have Been

This is a cool facebook app. Lets you pin all the places you have been for everyone to see.